CO129-122 - Sir MacDonnell - 1867 [5-6] — Page 211

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

had

a House the property of the known assigned to him in which he

was

bound

to reside and without the permission of the Government he could not reside elsewhere

while holding his office. Yet upon the authority of the Queen & Terrott, he

was

not exempted entirely from the Rate, but held liable rateably for the excess of accommodation above that

which was reasonably necessary for the performance of his public duties.

I cannot but think that the principle laid down in those decisions, must guide the case of Captain Barney whose occupancy of his house is not compulsory, and entirely for purposes unconnected with his public

Duties.

Having regard however to the weight

which is due to the opinion of my learned Predecessor and to the importance of the subject I hope the question will be referred home for solution.

(Signed) J Pauncefote Atty Genl

20th May 1867.

Edit History

2026-05-19 18:03:29 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
had a House the property of the known assigned to him in which he was bound to reside and without the permission of the Government he could not reside elsewhere while holding his office. Yet upon the authority of the Queen & Terrott, he was not exempted entirely from the Rate, but held liable rateably for the excess of accommodation above that which was reasonably necessary for the performance of his public duties. I cannot but think that the principle laid down in those decisions, must guide the case of Captain Barney whose occupancy of his house is not compulsory, and entirely for purposes unconnected with his public Duties. Having regard however to the weight which is due to the opinion of my learned Predecessor and to the importance of the subject I hope the question will be referred home for solution. (Signed) J Pauncefote Atty Genl 20th May 1867.
Baseline (Original)
had a House the property of the known assigned to him in which he was bound to resule and without the permission of the Government he could not reside elowhere while holding his office. Yet upon the authority of the Queen & Terrott, he AwaD not exempted entirely from the Rate, but held liable rateably for the excess of accommodation uleve that هم which was reasonably necessary for the P performance of his publie duties. I cannot but think that the principle laid down in those decisions, must quide the case of Captain baney whose occupancy of his house is not compulsory, and entirely for purposes unconnected with his public Duties. Having regard hawwer to the wright 20% which is due to the opinion of my leamed Predecesser and to the importance of the subject I hope the question will be referred home for solution. (Signed) J Pauncefate Atty Genk 20th May 1867. TA
2026-05-19 18:03:29 · Baseline
View content

had

a House the property of the known assigned to him in which he

was

bound

to resule and without the permission of the Government he could not reside elowhere

while holding his office. Yet upon the authority of the Queen & Terrott, he

AwaD

not exempted entirely from the Rate, but held liable rateably for the excess of accommodation uleve that

هم

which was reasonably necessary for the P performance of his publie duties.

I cannot but think that the principle laid down in those decisions, must quide the case of Captain baney whose occupancy of his house is not compulsory, and entirely for purposes unconnected with his public

Duties.

Having regard hawwer to the wright

20%

which is due to the opinion of my leamed Predecesser and to the importance of the subject I hope the question will be referred home for solution.

(Signed) J

Pauncefate Atty Genk

20th May 1867.

TA

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.